I’ve finally just got round to seeing the film version of the eternally popular 70s sitcom Dad’s Army. The mixed reviews it received meant I wasn’t enthused about seeing it, but in the end it was slightly better than I expected.
thing I found most interesting was seeing the acting choices that each member
of the ensemble cast took, which came down to either trying to play the
character or trying to play the actor who originally played the character. The
results were a mixed bag.
those who tried playing the character, I reckon Captain Mainwaring and Corporal Jones
both failed to work. I had thought that Toby Jones would be a good Mainwaring, a man
who’s a pompous idiot with an inferiority complex, but who, for all the
slapstick, is prepared to lead from the front and die for his men and country.
I didn’t get any of that, with Mainwaring just being a fat bald bloke who’s in
charge. This was doubly irritating as in the BBC’s Dad’s Army biopic John
Sessions was a perfect Arthur Lowe in both looks and mannerisms.
Jones was even worse bearing in mind that Tom Courtenay is one of the UK’s best
actors, but his Jones was just an annoying bloke who couldn’t be bothered to say
most of his numerous catchphrases. I think the mistake in casting was that
Clive Dunn was a young man playing an old man, so Jones was an amusing
caricature who could do all the slapstick nonsense, but getting an old actor to
play an old character just falls flat.
better ground was Bill Nighy, who made no effort to be either Sergeant Wilson or John Le
Mesurier, which was the right thing to do as only one man could ever master Wilson’s
affable ennui, and instead he did what he does in every film role I’ve ever
seen him in and was just Bill Nighy wandering around in a daze. Personally I
think they missed a trick, though, in not getting Ian Lavender to play Wilson,
which would have cemented one of the original sitcom’s best running jokes. Bill
Paterson was also acceptable as Private Frazer, although he had little to do, playing a dour Scotsman
rather than attempting to be John Laurie although, again, I reckon Ralph Riach in the BBC biopic was a better Laurie.
actors who decided to play the original actors feared much better. Michael
Gambon pretty much stole the show as Private Godfrey with all the best lines and a
perfect mimic of Arnold Ridley’s mannerisms and way of moving. Daniel Mays was
a fine James Beck, both looking and sounding like Private Walker, and I was most surprised
by whoever they got to be Private Pike. I don’t who that actor was, but I quickly started
to think of him as being Ian Lavender.
got together such a large ensemble cast, with most of the cast being acceptable
enough to make the reboot work, the strange thing was the decision to ignore
them for lengthy sections and instead waste time on telling a story. The sitcom
always worked perfectly when it was just the platoon standing in the church hall
listening to Mainwaring explain a perfectly simple mission to find German
parachutists disguised as nuns, while Wilson yawns and questions whether
Mainwaring is being wise, Godfrey gets told off for being awkward and asks to
be excused, Frazer pours scorn on Godfrey for being senile, Jones tells a
rambling story about the Sudan while waving his bayonet and getting slapped down
for going off in the realms of fantasy, Stupid boy Pike says his mum won’t let
him stay out late, and Walker offers to get his hands on some nuns’ habits
ninety minutes of that would have kept me amused because that’s what the show
is: a group of blokes coping with the boredom of waiting for something bad to
happen by irritating each other, but being always ready to go into battle or at
least extract Jones out of a combine harvester. Instead too much time was taken
up with the war, spies, romance, and other uninteresting nonsense, which often made me
think I was watching a comedy war film instead of Dad’s Army, which is a
character comedy set during the war.
the other hand the decision to spend more time with the usually underused female
characters worked well. Giving Mrs Fox and Godfrey’s sisters something to do
was fun, even though I was irritated to see Godfrey lived in town, and Mavis having
a role other than being Pike’s mum was entertaining. Strangest of all was the
decision to have Mainwaring’s wife on screen, which at first felt like
sacrilege, but is a good example of when it’s best to ignore canon. Maintaining
the running joke that we never see her wouldn’t work well in a one-off film, so
it was better to make her into a female version of Mainwaring.
I'd guess the inspiration for the story came from one of the sitcom's best episodes Mum's Army, in which Mainwaring decides to use the womenfolk to help out, which leads to him falling for one of the recruits. In half-an-hour that episode managed more laughs than the film managed, and the romance plot was more believable. Despite that,
on the whole, the film was a decent revival that works best if you’re in a good mood,
although I’d have still liked a few more jokes and a few more scenes where
the cast are standing together in the church hall trading catchphrases and
rambling on pointlessly.